Sunday, January 13, 2013

Who suffered more: me or Hamlet?

      I mean, sure, his dad died and what not, but he didn't have to annotate himself. Which is what most of the last... six weeks has consisted of. Minus break, of course. I have to admit, I really struggled with this one. Although I picked up on some of the Shakespearean terminology, most of it still left me confused, which made annotating really difficult. I usually try to have a good variety of DIDLS and personal reactions to the story line, but I couldn't get into the play enough to have good reactions to most parts. As a result, my copy of the play is covered in many little purple "diction," "syntax," and "language" notes. Which I guess isn't completely terrible, considering the fact that pretty much everything we do involves DIDLS. The one thing that really helped me through parts of the play was Ms.Holmes' commenting during our first read. I never would have picked up on a lot of what she told us.
      Still on the topic of Hamlet, comparing the movies was a kind of relief for me. I happened to picture the play almost exactly as Branagh did, so when we watched Bennett's version (I hope that's the right director, it took a good ten minutes to find him on the internet), I felt like I got everything wrong. Even though we only watched parts of Branagh's version, it helped me a lot with grasping some of scenes I either missed when we read them or just didn't understand.
      The other thing we did with Hamlet that impacted me was the use of language sheet we did. I missed the first part of class that day, so I only answered a few of the questions, but even just that was helpful. I hadn't really thought of Hamlet's use of language as being intentional; I just thought he liked to show off his superiority. Going through some of the scenes and focusing just on how he used language helped me focus on that more when I annotated other scenes I thought he might be using his language intentionally. That definitely helped me get some more purple "language" notes written.
      Not related to Hamlet, we started doing mood and atmosphere practices, which has been a very interesting experience in 3rd hour. Although we sometimes don't really focus on mood or atmosphere, we get there eventually, so we do get some practice in. And we do it in a fun way, which makes it more meaningful for me. Reading the other hours' examples also helps me more with mood, because I'm more of a reader than a writer, so sometimes I get more out of reading their examples than writing mine.

2 comments:

  1. You did really well including everything! I like how you included the movies and really got personal with the analysis of them. Nice job! I can't really find anything to critique on this!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Can't say I disagree with anything here. Hamlet's personality really makes it tedious to annotate. All he did for two months after his dad died was mope around the castle crying and making up long, wandering strings of philosophical musings that we, in turn, have to analyze. Thanks, Hamlet...
    On a more serious note, we seem to be doing a lot of in class reading rather than in class studying. Like you, I'm glad we have the occasional activity at the beginning of class to mix things up a bit, but I feel like we could be doing so much more.
    That isn't to say we are wasting our time, of course. Chances are, hardly anyone would understand anything were we not reading together in class. I just think we could be going much deeper than we are now.

    Noah Symanzik

    ReplyDelete